New AI tools that stitch together audio, video and text to make deceased loved ones appear to speak have sparked a fierce academic debate. Proponents tout the comfort of hearing a familiar voice again, yet scholars warn that the true impact lies elsewhere. Their "spectral labor" framework treats the resurrected persona as a source of raw data that can be harvested, packaged and sold without the consent of the departed or their families. By turning voice, likeness and even simulated emotion into marketable assets, these technologies blur the line between mourning and monetization. Critics argue that the promise of solace masks a deeper shift: grief is being redefined as a commodity, and the digital echo of a life becomes a labor force for content creators, advertisers and platform owners. The conversation now centers on who controls the posthumous image and whether the commodification of remembrance erodes the dignity owed to the dead.