Newville follows filmmakers Pisie Hochheim and Tony Oswald as they shadow ten siblings whose beliefs span the entire American political spectrum. The family embraces a wide range of spiritual beliefs and lifestyles, yet the documentary shows how they manage to "leave their swords at the door" when gathering, a sentiment emphasized by an aunt featured in the film. Centered on a household that resists easy political labeling, the story probes how love, loyalty, and dialogue endure amid deep disagreements. Through candid interviews and intimate scenes, Hochheim and Oswald explore how a diverse family navigates polarization, reconciles differences, and stays connected. This timely look at American family life, faith, and politics offers engaging insights for viewers interested in culture, politics, and the complexities of modern kinship.