Voters have reshaped the MVP landscape across MLB history, and the 2025 AL MVP race mirrors that evolution. This year’s debate centers on two standout candidates—Aaron Judge and Raleigh—and the various factors that could determine who takes home the award. As ballots approach, understanding how voting criteria have changed helps readers grasp what could tilt the race in favor of one star over the other. What drives the AL MVP decision in 2025 - Statistics and value: modern MVP conversations blend traditional counting stats with advanced metrics like WAR, OPS, on-base percentage, slugging, and defensive value, measuring a player’s overall contribution to wins. - Impact on the team: voters assess how a player’s performance translates into team success, including run production, lineup impact, and the ability to elevate teammates during key moments. - Durability and versatility: consistency across the season and the ability to contribute on both offense and defense can carry substantial weight. - Narrative and visibility: leadership, clutch performances, and memorable moments still shape voter perceptions, especially as the season unfolds and playoff races heat up. Judge’s case for AL MVP in 2025 - Consistent elite production: Judge’s power, plate discipline, and ability to drive runs place him firmly in the MVP conversation. - League-leading or near-top metrics: high WAR and standout offensive numbers strengthen his claim as the most valuable player on his team and in the league. - Franchise impact and narrative: Judge’s presence and influence within the Yankees’ lineup and their pursuit of a deep run add compelling context for voters. Raleigh’s case for AL MVP in 2025 - Breakout performance: Raleigh’s standout season showcases a breakout level of production that shifts the balance of power within his lineup. - Defensive value and versatility: contributions at premium positions and improved defense can tilt MVP discussions toward the player offering elite all-around value. - Momentum and pivotal moments: late-season surge and high-leverage performances can create compelling narratives that resonate with voters. How the two contenders compare on the most important metrics - War and on-base-plus-slugging: a direct look at overall value and offensive efficiency. - Defensive impact and positional value: how much a player contributes on the field beyond the batter’s box. - Team context and playoff potential: the extent to which each player helps his team contend down the stretch. - Narrative potential: the storyline each candidate presents as the season nears its climax. What this means for the 2025 AL MVP race - The winner could come down to the player delivering a more complete value package—whether through sustained production or game-changing moments in crucial games. - Late-season performances and playoff positioning may weigh heavily as votes are cast. - The award could reflect shifts in MVP criteria, balancing traditional power with all-around value and impact. Stay tuned for ongoing AL MVP coverage - In-depth analysis of Judge vs. Raleigh and how the voting landscape evolves throughout the season. - Metrics breakdowns, game logs, and clutch performances to inform your understanding of the race. - Updates on how this year’s AL MVP decision could shape MLB awards history. Note: Don’t miss out: limited-time discounts across all categories this week!